Reviews of online dating services, personals, singles, and matchmaking sites

Review Categories

** Top Rated **
General Dating Sites
United States Dating
Married But Looking
Jewish Dating
Christian Dating
Gay Personals
Canada Dating
Free Dating Sites

Forums

Visit the Forums!

Popular Reviews

eHarmony.com
Chemistry
Match.com
Yahoo Personals

Listings

Russian Brides
Dating Books
More Personals
Free Personals
Special Interest
Directories
Dating Advice
Foreign Brides I
Foreign Brides II
Miscellaneous

Shopping

Kate Spade
Persian Rugs

Other

Homepage
Online Dating Insider
About Us
Speed Dating
Ivy League Dating
Black Dating


PerfectMatch.com - Find Love Today


Start Searching Now
Yahoo! Personals - Believe

Reviews of Plentyoffish (Plenty Of Fish)


Write your own review!

1–3 of 3

Reviewed By
NewlySingle
NY

Sex
Female

Rating
*****

Date
November 11, 2008

permalink

Visit Plentyoffish (Plenty Of Fish)

I would have to disagree with the ratings given to this site. Like any dating service you are going to have the good, the bad and the ugly.

First off I would like to mention that this site is 100% free, so that gives it a major advantage over any other site. Don't like what you see? How can you complain? It's free! It costs nothing to join or contact other single people. You can keep your profile up with no maintenance and check your regular e-mail account that sends you notifications when someone e-mails you from POF.

This site is best for 20 something singles who are looking for dates and not looking to settle down. It is good for a temporary connection.

When I joined I received more e-mails than I ever did from any other pay site. I also received a ton of instant messages. (Which you can turn on or off in your preferences or allow only those on your favorite's list to contact you.)

The best feature of this site is that you can filter out who you want to contact you. For example: If you are looking for men, who are looking to only date, that are ages 18-25. Then that's who can e-mail you. It really eliminates the hassle.

The bad: The way the site is designed, it doesn't have a clean look like other sites and it's not as user friendly. I am a savvy computer user and it took me 5 minutes to find out where the delete button was in the inbox because it wasn't highlighted. I would say take a good 20 minutes to acquaint yourself with the site's features.

I have to say, I came across a lot of empty profiles, which was a bad sign. All you can do is e-mail the person you're interested in to find out what they're like. But, in my opinion it comes off as suspect.

The same reason why I think this site is good: for 20 something singles who are looking for dates and not looking to settle down, would be bad for others looking for something deeper. I'm not sure how many men are honestly looking for a girlfriend and long-term commitment, but like any site that's really determined by how well you can connect with someone. There are men who state they are looking for "someone special" but those are fewer and far between.

The Ugly: Well there are some desperate men on that site. There are men that are only looking for sex. Put those two together and it can be an ugly combination. You will have to be extra cautious and screen people before you give out your phone number or decide to meet! People lie so easily on the internet. The only thing I can say is try to talk to someone at least a week before you meet. See if they're consistent. See if they ask you general questions, but nothing too personal. Then meet up for coffee and take your own transportation. Its all common sense really.

Reviewed By
star
Augusta, GA

Sex
Male

Rating
*****

Date
October 29, 2008

permalink

Visit Plentyoffish (Plenty Of Fish)

This site should be named PLENTY OF ROTTEN FISH.com, because that is what it is. POF is the absolute bottom of the barrel (save maybe alt.com) when it comes to dating sites. You will find the absolute worst class of women on here of anywhere... who are all single and losers for good reason. Fat, tatooed divorcees in flip flops with bad teeth, or with anger management or other problems.

Reviewed By
jon
southern cali

Sex
Male

Rating
*****

Date
October 24, 2008

permalink

Visit Plentyoffish (Plenty Of Fish)

I have been on this site for a while, and I don't have too many complaints since the price is right. Had some dates, but nothing ever materialized. The quality of the girls, may be a tiny bit lower than the "paid" sites but it's negligible. On the plus side, vs. paid is that when you send out an email you are certain that the recipient can respond. Almost all paid sites, have "non-members" profiles up which have no way of responding so you waste lots of time emailing with no point. Of course, it carries many of the same pitfalls as paid sites such as a male to female ratio of around 5 to 1. (this is not a problem for females). One thing to note, it has a kind of quirky feature where you can have your picture rated. Warning, do not post your picture for ratings unless you want the remaining bit of self confidence you have destroyed. I am an avg looking guy, and I got rated a 2.8 out of 10. I would recommend it to anybody to try. Worst thing, you just wasted a bit of time.


1–3 of 3